Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen

Serving Key Largo since 1976, Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen is a true local institution right on the Overseas Highway. Walk in and you’re surrounded by a vibrant collection of license plates from all over the world, giving the room a rustic Old Florida feel that’s cozy, full of character, and exactly the kind of roadside gem you hope to find on a drive down the Keys. The kitchen turns out hearty, home-style cooking, from all-day breakfasts to fresh local seafood dinners.

Start with the chowders — a cup of Conch Chowder, and the Special Bacon and Shrimp Chowder, which is next level, so good you’ll want to drink it. The Blackened Mahi Mahi paired with their famous cottage fries is a winner (listen to your server on that one — they’re right). But the real showstopper is the Special Shrimp and Lobster Grilled Cheese: tender, sweet chunks of lobster and succulent shrimp in perfectly melted cheese between thick, buttery toasted bread — a total flavor bomb and a rare coastal take on a comfort classic. Finish with the house-made Key lime pie, the perfect balance of tart and sweet.

Featured in our Florida Keys locals’ guide — We actually eat there.