Islamorada Fish Company

The Islamorada Fish Company, uniquely located within the Bass Pro Shops – World Wide Sportsman complex in Islamorada, is more than just a convenient stop — it’s a destination, with a fantastic atmosphere and genuinely good food. If you’re driving to Key West, this is the essential break you need: a very large parking lot, reliable service, and a dining room that leans fully into the fishing theme. Check out the huge Bass Pro Shop, too, with the famous Pilar — Hemingway’s boat — right in the middle of the store.

Order the conch fritters first; in our review, we rated them among the best in the Keys. The smart play here is a spread of appetizers and soup instead of a full meal — the food is consistently pretty good, and it’s the perfect spot to graze. To round out the visit, you absolutely cannot miss the tarpon feeding, a unique and memorable activity that adds to the fun, Keys-like vibe. Book on OpenTable to earn points, and make this your planned pause on the Overseas Highway.