Pepe’s Cafe

Historic Legacy: Established in 1909, it is the oldest eating establishment in the Florida Keys and the second-oldest in the entire state of Florida (with regular historical patrons including President Harry S. Truman).

Scratch-Made Philosophy: Emphasizes fresh preparation with daily house-baked breads, house-made salad dressings, proprietary hot sauces, and no freezers on-site except for ice cream.

Fresh-Shucked Seafood & Raw Bar: Known for oysters shucked fresh to order, along with daily seafood and steak offerings.

Award-Winning Cocktails: Voted Best Mojito and Best Margarita in Key West (2026 BUBBAS: People’s Choice Awards), highlighted by fresh-squeezed citrus juices.

All-Day Service: Serves dedicated breakfast (7:30 AM – Noon), lunch (Noon – 5:00 PM), and dinner (5:00 PM – 9:30 PM) menus seven days a week.

Daily Happy Hour: Runs every day from 4:00 PM to 6:00 PM featuring deals on oysters, half-priced wine, and drinks.

Pet-Friendly Dining: Welcomes pets in their outdoor patio seating area.

On-Site & Online Merchandise: Sells proprietary bottled hot sauces, apparel, mugs, and branded gifts.